Skip to Content
Call Us Today! 904-615-8950
Top
Shoplifting / Petit Theft

Jacksonville Shoplifting Attorney

Protect Your Rights. Trust The Law Offices of Kate Mesic, P.A.

Petit theft is often associated with shoplifting. Florida Statute 812.014 defines petit theft as knowingly obtaining, using, or attempting to obtain or use another person’s property with the intent to deprive that person of it, either temporarily or permanently. Even temporarily taking someone else’s property can be considered a theft offense in Florida.

Amount Stolen or Property ValueLevel of OffenseMaximum FL Penalties
Less than $100.002nd degree petit theft60 days in jail / $500.00 fine
$100.00 to $749.001st degree petit theft1 year in jail / $1,000.00 fine
$750.00 or more3rd degree grand theft felony5 years in prison / $5,000.00 fine
Prior theft convictionA later petit theft is elevated to a 1st degree misdemeanor1 year in jail / $1,000.00 fine
2 or more prior theft convictionsA later petit theft can be charged as a 3rd degree felony5 years in prison / $5,000.00 fine

Shoplifting is sometimes labeled a minor offense, but it’s a crime. A conviction leaves you with a criminal record, so every criminal charge should be taken seriously. Call The Law Offices of Kate Mesic, P.A. for a free consultation if you or a loved one has been arrested or received a Notice to Appear for petit theft or shoplifting.

Contact our Jacksonville shoplifting lawyer at (904) 615-8950 today.

Experienced Jacksonville Theft Defense Lawyers Ready to Assist

A Jacksonville criminal defense lawyer can explain the charge and review the evidence against you. Evidence commonly includes:

  • Store video
  • Testimony from store employees
  • Witness testimony
  • Statements or admissions allegedly made to police or other witnesses

We obtain this information through discovery, the process that requires the State Attorney’s Office to disclose the evidence it intends to use. To secure a conviction at trial, the prosecutor must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the accused took the property with the intent to steal it.

If dismissal isn’t possible, our defense attorneys can explore potential alternatives to jail, including:

  • Probation
  • Counseling: take a court-ordered class
  • Withholding of adjudication: not a conviction
  • Diversion program: PTI
  • Restitution in the amount of the stolen property to the store
  • Community service

A petit theft conviction can also affect driving privileges, academic scholarships, personal relationships, and the trust of people around you.

Many of these cases arise in stores such as Wal-Mart and Target. Sometimes people are charged even though they didn’t intend to steal, such as when they forgot an item in the cart. Every detail matters to your Jacksonville criminal defense lawyer, so tell your lawyer exactly what happened.

Self-Checkout Errors & Forgotten Items

A missed scan, an unpaid item left in a cart, or a distracted departure requires close review of the surrounding facts. Florida theft law requires the state to prove that a person acted knowingly and intended to deprive the merchant of the property or its value. An accusation alone doesn’t resolve those questions.

Shoplifting allegations can also involve claims that someone altered a price tag, transferred merchandise into another container, or left with merchandise without paying. We examine transaction records, store video, receipts, witness accounts, and alleged statements to determine what the evidence shows about knowledge and intent.

Retail Theft Detention in Florida

A Florida merchant, employee, or agent with probable cause to believe shoplifting occurred and that the property can be recovered may detain a person in a reasonable manner for a reasonable time. The detention must be intended to recover the property or support prosecution of the alleged offense.

Once a merchant or employee takes someone into custody for suspected retail theft, law enforcement must be called to the scene immediately. Florida law also protects a merchant or employee from false-arrest and false-imprisonment liability when probable cause existed. The circumstances of the detention, any search, and the collection of evidence remain important parts of our review.

4 Tips to Keep in Mind When Charged with Petit Theft in Florida

*These tips apply to other criminal offenses as well.

  • Stay calm and be polite: You can be firm without being rude. Arguing with police won’t help, and you don’t want an additional resisting arrest charge. In most cases, police will issue a Notice to Appear, but resisting can lead to jail. If you believe your rights are being violated, get the names and badge numbers of every officer involved.
  • Get help: Hire a criminal lawyer in Jacksonville, FL. Representing yourself in a criminal case is risky because an offer that appears favorable may carry consequences you don’t recognize.
  • Be part of the defense team: Talk to your criminal lawyer about the strengths and weaknesses of your case and discuss the evidence against you.
  • While in court: Dress appropriately. Don’t wear shorts, sneakers, or short skirts. Choose clothing you would wear to church or a job interview, and be polite and respectful.

What Are Common Defenses Against Shoplifting Charges?

The right defense depends on the specific facts of the accusation. Common defenses focus on intent, identity, the strength of the evidence, and the procedures used by store personnel.

Lack of Intent
Prosecutors must prove that the accused knowingly took an item with the intent to deprive the merchant of its property or value. If someone accidentally left with an unpaid item or mistakenly placed it in a bag, the surrounding evidence may support a lack-of-intent defense.

Mistaken Identity
In a busy store, security personnel may identify the wrong person. This can happen when several customers are near the merchandise or surveillance footage is unclear.

Insufficient Evidence
The prosecution must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. Unclear surveillance footage, disputed witness testimony, or other gaps in the evidence may prevent the state from meeting that burden.

Improper Detention or Search Procedures
Stores and security personnel must follow legal procedures when detaining and accusing someone of shoplifting. An unlawful detention or search, along with any resulting evidence, must be evaluated as part of the defense.

Each defense can play an important role in protecting your rights and addressing the long-term consequences of a shoplifting conviction.

Facing theft charges in Florida can be frightening and overwhelming, but you don’t have to navigate the process alone. Call our Jacksonville defense attorneys at (904) 615-8950 for your free consultation.

Further Reading: Petit Theft Blog Posts

These resources explain Florida petit theft law, court procedure, self-checkout allegations, and related civil claims in greater detail:

Frequently Asked Questions About Florida Petit Theft Charges:

1. What’s the difference between petit theft and grand theft in Florida?

Under Florida Statute § 812.014, petit theft generally applies when the property is worth less than $750. It’s charged as a misdemeanor, although repeat convictions can elevate the charge. Grand theft generally applies when the value is $750 or more or the property falls into a special category, such as a motor vehicle, firearm, or law enforcement equipment. The felony carries more severe penalties, including possible prison time. Because the classification has long-term consequences, the property value and supporting evidence require careful review.


2. Can theft charges be dropped in Florida?

Yes. The State Attorney’s Office can dismiss a charge when the evidence is weak or as part of negotiations. Depending on the facts and available programs, an attorney can pursue dismissal, reduction, or another resolution involving restitution, community service, or diversion. Prosecutors have discretion when filing or reducing charges, and a Jacksonville theft lawyer can advocate for an appropriate resolution early in the process.


3. What’s a diversion program for theft?

A diversion program, such as Pretrial Intervention (PTI), is an alternative to traditional prosecution. If accepted, you may need to complete counseling, anti-theft classes, restitution, community service, or other conditions. Upon successful completion, the prosecutor may dismiss the case, and you may avoid a conviction. Not everyone qualifies. Eligibility and admission depend on the charge, criminal history, available program, and prosecutorial approval.


4. Can a petit theft conviction be sealed or expunged?

If your petit theft is dropped or you receive a withhold of adjudication and meet Florida’s eligibility requirements, you may be able to petition the court to seal or expunge your record. If you were adjudicated guilty, even of misdemeanor theft, the record can’t be sealed or expunged under Florida law. Early intervention matters because the disposition affects whether sealing or expungement is available.


5. What happens if this is my second theft charge?

One prior conviction elevates a later petit theft charge to a first-degree misdemeanor, even if the property value would otherwise support a lower charge. Two or more such convictions can result in a third-degree felony charge punishable by up to 5 years in prison. They can also affect eligibility for diversion programs. A defense may focus on intent, the evidence, or the classification of the alleged conduct.


6. Will a conviction for theft affect my ability to get a job?

It can. Theft is considered a crime of dishonesty, which may concern employers, landlords, and licensing boards, particularly in fields involving money handling, retail, banking, healthcare, or law enforcement. A conviction can also affect professional licenses such as nursing or teaching. The consequences depend on the position, licensing rules, background-check policies, and case disposition.


7. What evidence does the state rely on in theft cases?

Common evidence includes surveillance video, store security reports, witness testimony, receipts, and alleged statements from the accused. The state must still prove the charge beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense attorney can challenge unclear video, disputed identification, and improperly obtained evidence, including through a motion to suppress when supported by the facts.


8. Is shoplifting treated as theft in Florida?

Shoplifting allegations are prosecuted under Florida’s theft statute. The merchandise value affects whether the charge is classified as petit theft or a felony, but the state must still prove knowledge and intent. Even an allegation involving a low-value item can lead to a criminal charge and should be taken seriously.


9. How long does a theft case take to resolve?

In Duval County and surrounding counties, timing depends on the seriousness of the charge, the evidence, and the complexity of the case. Discovery, motions to suppress, negotiations with prosecutors, court scheduling, and diversion-program availability can all affect the timeline. An attorney can track deadlines and explain each procedural stage as the case develops.


10. Can I be charged with theft if I accidentally forgot to pay?

Yes, you can face an allegation after forgetting to scan an item at self-checkout or leaving a store with unpaid merchandise. Florida law still requires proof that you acted knowingly and intended to deprive the merchant of the property or its value. Receipts, transaction records, surveillance footage, and the surrounding circumstances can be important when evaluating intent.


11. What are the collateral consequences of a petit theft plea or conviction?

In addition to jail, fines, and probation, collateral consequences can include:

  • Suspension of your driver’s license
  • Loss of scholarships or financial aid
  • Ineligibility for housing assistance
  • Barriers to certain professional licenses
  • Immigration consequences for non-citizens

These indirect penalties can have a long-term impact beyond the court sentence, so the potential disposition and record consequences deserve careful attention.


12. What’s the role of restitution in a theft case?

Restitution repays the value of stolen or damaged property. It may be part of a plea, sentence, diversion agreement, or negotiated resolution. Whether and when to pay depends on the case, so discuss restitution with your attorney before contacting the retailer or making a payment.


13. Can I represent myself in a theft case?

Legally, yes, but doing so is highly risky. Florida petit theft law is complex, and prosecutors won’t give you leniency simply because you don’t have a lawyer. Self-representation increases the risk of missing defenses, overlooking procedural issues, or accepting a plea without understanding its consequences. A lawyer can review the evidence, present available defenses, and handle negotiations based on the facts of your case.

Discuss Your Shoplifting or Petit Theft Charge

Our shoplifting attorney in Jacksonville can review the allegation, the evidence concerning intent, and the available options for addressing the charge. We provide consultations for people facing shoplifting and petit theft matters.

Call (904) 615-8950 or use our contact form to request a consultation with The Law Offices of Kate Mesic, P.A..

Our Settlements & Verdicts

Our top priority is to devise customized legal strategies that are tailored to the unique legal needs of our clients, no matter how simple or complicated their situations, might be.

  • Charges dropped Accident-Failed to Give Information and Improper Backing
  • Dismissed Accident-Leaving the Scene, Careless Driving
  • Expunged Allow Minor Alcohol at Open House Party.
  • Charges Dropped Allow Minor Alcohol ot Drugs at Open House Party
  • 1 count of battery amended, others dropped Battery
  • Withhold of Adjudication Battery

Contact The Law Offices of Kate Mesic, P.A. Today!

A member of our team will be in touch shortly to confirm your contact details or address questions you may have.

  • Please enter your first name.
  • Please enter your last name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.
  • By submitting, you agree to receive text messages from The Law Offices of Kate Mesic, P.A. at the number provided, including those related to your inquiry, follow-ups, and review requests, via automated technology. Consent is not a condition of purchase. Msg & data rates may apply. Msg frequency may vary. Reply STOP to cancel or HELP for assistance. Acceptable Use Policy
Locations